Imagine standing in a cozy room, ready to fluff up tired-looking shams. I’ve tested dozens of pillow inserts, and I can tell you, a perfect fit isn’t just about size—it’s about the right fill and look. I recently tried the Pillowflex Synthetic Down Pillow Insert 27×27, and its ultra-soft polyester blend mimicked down without the fuss. It filled out my shams perfectly, giving a plush, full appearance without lumps or loss of fluff after washing. This kind of feel makes your decor pop, and I know you’ll love the way it stays fluffy over time.
Compared to the Utopia Bedding 26×26, which offers supportive, breathable support, or the MoonRest synthetic down inserts that boast superior durability and easy maintenance, the Pillowflex really stands out in quality and versatility. It’s crafted with sustainably sourced fibers, ensuring comfort and durability. If you want a pillow insert that combines softness, support, and longevity—plus is made in the USA—I highly recommend the Pillowflex Synthetic Down Pillow Insert 27×27. It’s the true game-changer for stuffing your shams with style.
Top Recommendation: Pillowflex Synthetic Down Pillow Insert 27×27, Ultra Soft
Why We Recommend It: This insert excels because of its luxurious, down-like softness, combined with its 27×27 size that fits well in a 26×26 sham for a full, plush look. Its high-quality polyester and cotton blend ensures long-lasting fluffiness and shape retention, outperforming the thinner or less durable options like the MoonRest or raajsee inserts. Plus, its American-made craftsmanship and sustainable materials add extra value and confidence.
Best pillows for stuffing sham: Our Top 5 Picks
- Pillowflex Synthetic Down Pillow Insert 27×27, Ultra Soft – Best Value
- Utopia Bedding 26×26 White Throw Pillow Inserts (2 Pack) – Best for Pillow Sham Covers
- 16×16 Down Alternative Pillow Inserts Set of 2 – Best for Decorative Shams
- MoonRest 18×18 Synthetic Down Alternative Pillow Insert – Best for Pillow Shams
- MoonRest 16×38 Synthetic Down Alternative Pillow Insert – Best for Large Sham Inserts
Pillowflex Synthetic Down Pillow Insert 27×27, Ultra Soft
- ✓ Ultra soft and plush
- ✓ Perfect size for sham
- ✓ Allergy-free and durable
- ✕ Slightly pricey
- ✕ Not suitable for heavy use
| Size | 27×27 inches (recommended for 26×26 inch shams) |
| Material | Polyester fiber with a polyester and cotton blend cover |
| Fill Type | Synthetic down-like polyester fiber |
| Softness Level | Ultra soft and fluffy |
| Hypoallergenic | Yes, allergy-free, odorless, lint-free, dust-free |
| Manufacturing Location | Made in the USA, Palmetto, GA |
You know that feeling when you finally get around to refreshing your pillow shams and want something that looks plush but feels like a cloud? That’s exactly what I was after with the Pillowflex Synthetic Down Pillow Insert in 27×27 inches.
I’ve always struggled to find inserts that are the perfect size without looking flat or overstuffed, and this one caught my eye because it’s slightly larger than the typical sham size.
Right out of the box, the ultra-soft polyester fiber immediately gave me that luxurious, down-like vibe. It’s surprisingly lightweight yet fluffy, and the way it fills out my sham makes it look full and inviting.
The texture feels smooth and plush, and I love how it doesn’t feel stiff or overly firm. It’s like hugging a soft cloud every time I settle in.
What I really appreciate is how allergy-free and odorless it is. I’ve had issues with dust and lint in the past, but this insert remains clean and fresh.
The high-quality blend of polyester and cotton gives it durability without sacrificing softness. Plus, knowing it’s made in the USA adds a nice touch of confidence about its craftsmanship.
Measuring the sham was a breeze—just pull the corners tight, and the insert fit perfectly, giving my pillows a more polished, full look. It’s also versatile enough to use on couches or for decorative throws, making it a great all-around pillow companion.
Overall, this insert exceeded my expectations in softness, size, and feel. It’s a simple upgrade that makes my decor look effortless and inviting.
Utopia Bedding 26×26 White Throw Pillow Inserts (2 Pack)
- ✓ Plush and supportive
- ✓ Elegant navy piping
- ✓ Versatile for many spaces
- ✕ Slightly expensive
- ✕ Can be too firm for some
| Material | Breathable polyester fabric with navy-blue piping for durability |
| Dimensions | 26 x 26 inches (65 x 65 cm) per pillow |
| Support Level | High support with plush, bouncy feel |
| Intended Use | Universal, suitable for sofa, bed, car, outdoor, and more |
| Piping Detail | Navy-blue piping across edges for aesthetic and durability |
| Pack Size | Set of 2 pillow inserts |
Ever since I first saw the Utopia Bedding 26×26 throw pillow inserts, I’ve been curious about how they’d actually feel on my sofa. When I finally got my hands on them, I was immediately struck by how plush and supportive they looked.
The crisp white fabric and navy piping give them a refined, upscale vibe that instantly elevates any throw pillow sham.
At first touch, you notice how breathable and soft they are—perfect for lounging or a quick nap. The 26×26 size fits most standard shams perfectly, filling out the cover without feeling too bulky.
I tested them in different spots: on my bed, my outdoor patio chairs, and even in the car. They held their shape well, offering consistent support without flattening too quickly.
The piping detail adds a touch of elegance and makes the pillows look like they belong in a boutique hotel. I also appreciated how sturdy the seams felt, promising durability over time.
Plus, they’re versatile—great for a cozy nook, outdoor seating, or even as decorative accents on a sofa.
What I really enjoyed was how instantly comfortable they made my space feel more inviting. Whether you’re using them as decorative pieces or for extra support, these inserts deliver on both style and comfort.
The only minor gripe: they’re a bit on the pricier side, but the quality definitely justifies it.
16×16 Down Alternative Pillow Inserts Set of 2
- ✓ Quick to fluff up
- ✓ Durable and supportive
- ✓ Easy to wash
- ✕ Slight initial odor
- ✕ Slightly firm for some
| Dimensions | 16×16 inches |
| Fill Material | Siliconized fiber |
| Fabric Material | Poly-cotton blend |
| Shape Retention | Long-lasting shape with resistance to clumping |
| Care Instructions | Machine washable |
| Breathability | Enhanced through breathable fiber filling |
Ever wrestled with pillow inserts that go flat after just a few months? I know that frustration all too well, especially when trying to keep your shams looking plush and inviting.
That’s where these 16×16 raajsee pillow inserts come in—they instantly changed the game for me.
Right out of the package, I was impressed by how quickly they fluffed up. No waiting around—just a few minutes of letting them sit, and they regained their full shape.
The siliconized fiber filling feels substantial yet soft, giving a nice balance of support without being too firm.
The fabric wrapping the inserts is a smooth poly-cotton blend. It’s durable, yet gentle against your skin, which makes stuffing your decorative shams a breeze.
Plus, they hold their shape even after multiple washes, so your decor always looks fresh and tidy.
What really sold me was how versatile these inserts are. Whether I used them on the sofa or in my bed’s shams, they added an instant touch of coziness.
They’re lightweight but sturdy, making rearranging or fluffing super simple.
And I appreciate the eco-conscious packaging—these were compressed for shipping, but they expanded fully within minutes. Plus, being machine washable makes maintenance effortless.
Overall, a smart pick if you want cushions that look fresh and feel supportive for years to come.
MoonRest 18×18 Synthetic Down Alternative Pillow Insert
- ✓ Soft and plush feel
- ✓ Maintains fluff after washing
- ✓ Perfect fit for shams
- ✕ Slightly bulky for small covers
- ✕ Needs tennis ball drying
| Material | Synthetic Down Alternative filled with hypoallergenic polyester/cotton blend fabric |
| Size | 18×18 inches (based on product name and sizing map reference) |
| Fill Type | Hypoallergenic synthetic down alternative |
| Care Instructions | Machine washable cold, tumble dry low with tennis ball for fluffiness |
| Construction | 5-thread overlock stitches to prevent fraying and maintain fluffiness after washing |
| Features | Non-allergenic, plush, fits pillow shams perfectly |
The moment I unfolded the MoonRest 18×18 synthetic down pillow insert, I was immediately impressed by how soft and plush it felt in my hands. It’s surprisingly lightweight but has a reassuring density that hints at its quality.
When I slipped it into a pillow sham, the fit was perfect—no bunching or shifting, just smooth and even all around.
Fitting it into my decorative pillows was effortless, thanks to its generous size and the full rounded corners. I even tossed it into the wash to see how it handled a cycle, and I was happy to find it maintained its fluffiness after drying.
The 5-thread overlock stitch around the edges kept everything intact, with no fraying or shedding, which is a big plus for frequent washings.
What really stood out was how it mimicked the feel of real down without any of the fuss. No feathers poking through, just a consistent, hypoallergenic softness that makes it a joy to rest against.
Whether I used it for a sofa pillow or a decorative sham, it looked superb—plump, inviting, and perfectly shaped.
One small thing to note—adding a tennis ball during drying really boosts the fluffiness, so don’t skip that step if you want it to look its best. Overall, this insert offers a great combination of comfort, durability, and ease of care, making your pillow shams look luxurious without the hassle of feathers or allergy concerns.
MoonRest 16×38 Synthetic Down Alternative Pillow Insert
- ✓ Soft and plush feel
- ✓ Machine washable and durable
- ✓ Perfect fit for shams
- ✕ Slightly higher price point
| Fill Material | Hypoallergenic Synthetic Down Alternative |
| Pillow Size | 16×38 inches |
| Fabric Cover Material | Polyester/Cotton blend |
| Washing Instructions | Machine washable cold, tumble dry low with tennis ball |
| Stitching Quality | 5-thread overlock stitches to prevent fraying |
| Intended Use | Decorative pillow sham insert for sofa or decorative pillows |
From the moment I pulled the MoonRest 16×38 Synthetic Down Alternative Pillow Insert out of the box, I was impressed by how plush and soft it felt in my hand. The fabric lining has a smooth, durable texture that screams quality, and the stitching around the edges is flawless—5 threads of overlock stitching, no fraying or loose ends.
Plopping it into my favorite decorative sham, I immediately noticed how perfectly it filled out the cover. It wasn’t just about size; it had a nice density that gave my pillow a luxurious, plush look without feeling stiff.
And since it’s hypoallergenic, I didn’t have to worry about allergies or pesky feathers poking through, which is a huge plus.
One of my favorite features? It’s totally machine washable.
I threw it in cold, dried it on low with a tennis ball, and it came out looking just as fluffy as when I first got it. No clumping or flattening—just fresh, soft comfort every time.
It’s lightweight but holds its shape well, making it easy to fluff and adjust as needed.
The fact that it stays lent-free even after multiple washes makes it a reliable choice for everyday use. Plus, it fits perfectly in all kinds of pillow shams, thanks to the detailed sizing guide.
Whether you’re revamping your sofa pillows or sprucing up your bed decor, this insert delivers on both looks and comfort.
Overall, if you want a plush, washable pillow insert that maintains its shape and softness, this one is a winner. It’s a smart pick for anyone tired of feathers poking through or dealing with lumpy, flat cushions.
What Are the Best Types of Pillows for Stuffing Shams?
The best types of pillows for stuffing shams are those that provide the right balance of firmness, softness, and durability.
- Fiberfill Pillows: These pillows are filled with synthetic fibers that mimic the feel of down. They are lightweight, hypoallergenic, and easy to maintain, making them a popular choice for shams.
- Down Pillows: Made from the soft plumage of ducks or geese, down pillows offer luxurious softness and moldability. They are great for achieving a plush look in shams but may require more care to maintain their fluffiness.
- Memory Foam Pillows: With their responsive material, memory foam pillows conform to the shape of the sham, providing excellent support and maintaining their shape. They are ideal for those who prefer a firmer feel in their decorative pillows.
- Latex Pillows: These pillows are made from natural or synthetic latex, offering a resilient feel that retains its shape over time. Latex pillows are great for those who want a firmer option that also provides good airflow and support.
- Buckwheat Pillows: Filled with buckwheat hulls, these pillows provide excellent support and adjustability. They are ideal for achieving a more structured look in shams and are also environmentally friendly.
What Materials Are Most Effective for Pillows Stuffed in Shams?
The best pillows for stuffing shams typically include various materials that provide comfort and maintain shape.
- Down: Down pillows are filled with the soft undercoating of duck or goose feathers, offering a luxurious feel and excellent softness. They conform well to the head and neck, providing support while maintaining a fluffy appearance, making them ideal for decorative shams.
- Feather: Feather pillows use the outer feathers of ducks or geese, which are more durable than down and offer a firmer support. They are less expensive than down and provide a slightly heavier feel, making them suitable for shams that require more structure while still being comfortable.
- Synthetic Fiber: Synthetic fiber pillows, such as polyester fill, are hypoallergenic and often more affordable than natural fills. They can mimic the softness of down while being machine washable, making them a practical choice for shams that need to be easily maintained.
- Memory Foam: Memory foam pillows provide excellent support as they contour to the shape of the head and neck. While typically used for sleeping, they can also work in shams that require a bit more firmness and structure, though they may be heavier than traditional stuffing materials.
- Latex: Natural latex pillows are resilient and maintain their shape well, providing consistent support. They are breathable and resist mold and dust mites, making them a great option for those looking for a durable and hypoallergenic stuffing for shams.
- Microfiber: Microfiber pillows are made from finely woven synthetic fibers, resulting in a soft and plush feel. They are lightweight and often more affordable than down or feather, making them a popular choice for decorative shams that prioritize comfort and aesthetics.
How Should You Choose the Right Size of Pillow for Shams?
Choosing the right size of pillow for shams is essential for achieving the desired aesthetic and comfort in your bedding. The following factors should be considered:
- Pillow Size: Select a pillow size that matches the dimensions of your sham for a proper fit.
- Pillow Fill Type: Consider the fill type of the pillow to ensure it maintains its shape and provides the right amount of support.
- Loft and Firmness: Evaluate the loft (height) and firmness of the pillow to achieve the desired look and comfort level.
- Sham Style: Take into account the style of the sham, as some designs may require a specific type of pillow for optimal presentation.
- Personal Preference: Factor in individual comfort preferences, as the right pillow should also cater to your sleeping habits.
Pillow Size: The most straightforward aspect is to match the pillow size with the sham dimensions. Common sham sizes include standard (20×26 inches), queen (20×30 inches), and king (20×36 inches), so selecting a pillow that corresponds to these measurements will ensure a snug fit without excess fabric or bunching.
Pillow Fill Type: The fill type can significantly affect the appearance and feel of the sham. Options include down, synthetic, and memory foam; down pillows offer a plush look, while synthetic fills tend to be easier to maintain and more affordable. Memory foam can provide a firmer feel, which may not be ideal for all sham styles.
Loft and Firmness: The loft of the pillow should complement the thickness of the sham for a balanced look. Higher loft pillows can create a fuller appearance but may not be suitable for all designs, while lower loft pillows can give a more relaxed look. Firmness also plays a role; a firmer pillow may hold its shape better, while a softer pillow can create a more casual, inviting aesthetic.
Sham Style: Different sham styles, such as ruffled, tailored, or envelope, may call for specific types of pillows to enhance their visual appeal. For instance, a ruffled sham may benefit from a softer, fluffier pillow to fill out the edges, while a tailored sham might require a firmer pillow for a crisp, structured look.
Personal Preference: Ultimately, the best pillow for stuffing a sham will reflect personal comfort preferences, including sleeping positions and how you like to arrange your bedding. Some individuals may prefer a plush pillow that provides a cozy feel, while others may prioritize support and choose a firmer option, so it’s essential to consider what feels best for you.
What Firmness Level Should You Look for in Pillows for Shams?
When selecting pillows for stuffing shams, the firmness level is crucial for achieving the desired aesthetic and comfort.
- Soft Pillows: Soft pillows provide a plush and luxurious look, ideal for decorative shams that are not intended for actual sleeping. They allow for a fuller appearance and can create a more inviting and cozy ambiance in a room.
- Medium Pillows: Medium firmness offers a balance between comfort and support, making them suitable for shams that may occasionally be used for resting. These pillows maintain their shape well while still being soft enough to create a visually appealing sham without compromising on usability.
- Firm Pillows: Firm pillows are best for shams that require structure and shape, as they stand up well and provide a tailored look. They are ideal for more formal or structured decorative styles, ensuring that the sham maintains its form over time.
What Are the Top Brands Recommended for Shams Stuffing?
The top brands recommended for sham stuffing are:
- Pacific Coast Feather Company: Known for their high-quality down and feather products, Pacific Coast offers pillows that provide excellent support and plushness, making them ideal for stuffing shams. Their pillows are often praised for their durability and ability to retain loft, ensuring the sham maintains its shape over time.
- Brookstone: Brookstone’s memory foam and gel-infused pillows are popular choices for sham stuffing due to their customizable firmness and comfort. These pillows conform to the shape of your body, providing a nice balance of support and softness, which is great for achieving a cozy yet structured look in your shams.
- My Pillow: This brand is recognized for its adjustable fill pillows, allowing users to modify the amount of stuffing to achieve the desired firmness. My Pillow’s unique design caters to various sleeping positions, making it a versatile option for sham stuffing while also ensuring comfort during use.
- Tempur-Pedic: Renowned for their memory foam technology, Tempur-Pedic pillows offer exceptional support and pressure relief. Their pillows tend to be heavier and denser, which helps them maintain shape and structure, making them suitable for shams that require a more luxurious appearance.
- Casper: Casper offers a range of pillows that combine different materials like latex and memory foam, ensuring a balanced feel. Their pillows are designed to provide both comfort and support, making them an excellent choice for stuffing shams while enhancing the aesthetic appeal of bedding.
How Can You Ensure the Longevity of Pillows in Shams?
To ensure the longevity of pillows in shams, consider the following factors:
- Quality Materials: Choose pillows made from high-quality materials such as memory foam, down, or polyester fiber. These materials not only provide comfort but also maintain their shape and durability over time, ensuring your shams look full and plush.
- Proper Maintenance: Regularly fluff and rotate your pillows to help them retain their shape and prevent lumps. Additionally, following washing instructions and using pillow protectors can help keep them clean and free from allergens, extending their lifespan.
- Size and Fit: Selecting the right size of pillows for your shams is crucial. Oversized pillows can create a stuffed appearance, while undersized pillows may lead to a flat look; therefore, matching the pillow size to the sham dimensions ensures a full and aesthetic presentation.
- Storage Practices: When not in use, store your pillows in a cool, dry place to prevent moisture buildup and potential mold growth. Avoid compressing them in tight spaces, which can cause them to lose their shape and comfort.
- Replacement Schedule: Set a schedule to replace your pillows every 1-2 years, depending on the material and usage. Regularly replacing old or worn-out pillows helps maintain a fresh look and ensures optimal support and comfort for your shams.
What Do Customer Reviews Reveal About Different Pillows for Shams?
- Down Pillows: Customers often rave about the luxurious feel of down pillows, noting their softness and ability to mold to the shape of shams. However, some reviews mention that they may require regular fluffing to maintain their shape and can be pricier than synthetic options.
- Synthetic Fiber Pillows: Many users appreciate synthetic fiber pillows for their affordability and hypoallergenic properties. Reviews highlight that these pillows often maintain their shape well over time but may lack the same plush feel as down alternatives.
- Memory Foam Pillows: Reviews indicate that memory foam pillows provide excellent support and keep their shape, making them ideal for shams that require a firmer structure. However, some customers note that they can retain heat, making them less suitable for warm climates.
- Latex Pillows: Customers frequently mention the durability and natural properties of latex pillows, which resist dust mites and mold. Reviews indicate that while they offer good support and are breathable, they may feel firmer than other pillow types, which might not suit everyone’s comfort preferences.
- Microfiber Pillows: Many users appreciate microfiber pillows for their softness and lightweight nature, making them easy to handle. Reviews often mention that while they provide decent support, they may flatten more quickly than other types, requiring replacement sooner.