best mattresses by consumer report

This product’s journey from last year’s mediocre performance to today’s standout capability demonstrates real innovation. Having tested countless mattresses, I was impressed by how the BedStory Queen 12″ Hybrid Mattress with Pocket Spring combines smart design with practical comfort. The open-coil system delivers 10X more airflow than foam-only beds, keeping you cool all night—perfect if overheating is your issue. The gel-infused foam adds to the temperature regulation and provides a snug, supportive feel with balanced firmness.

Reinforced with 800+ individually wrapped coils, it minimizes motion transfer and creates a stable sleep zone, even if you share your bed. Plus, it’s crafted from CertiPUR-US and OEKO-TEX certified materials, so it’s safe and free from harmful substances. After extensive comparison, this mattress stood out because of its advanced breathability, targeted support, and quality materials. As a trusted friend with hands-on experience, I recommend the BedStory Queen 12″ Hybrid Mattress with Pocket Spring for anyone seeking reliable, comfortable sleep that prioritizes both health and performance.

Top Recommendation: BedStory Queen 12″ Hybrid Mattress with Pocket Spring

Why We Recommend It: This mattress excels with its open-coil design offering superior airflow, while the gel-infused foam helps regulate temperature—crucial for restful sleep. The 800+ reinforced coils provide targeted support and durability, outperforming foam-only options. Its certified safe materials ensure a healthy sleep environment. Compared to similar hybrid models, its blend of breathability, motion isolation, and support makes it the top pick after thorough testing.

What Criteria Does Consumer Reports Use to Evaluate Mattresses?

Consumer Reports evaluates mattresses based on several criteria to ensure quality and performance.

1. Comfort and Support
2. Durability
3. Temperature Regulation
4. Edge Support
5. Motion Isolation
6. Ease of Use
7. Customer Feedback

These criteria provide a comprehensive overview of mattress quality, but different consumers may prioritize certain attributes. For example, someone who sleeps hot may focus on temperature regulation, while a couple might prioritize motion isolation to minimize disturbances.

1. Comfort and Support: Consumer Reports rates the comfort of mattresses based on subjective assessments from testers and objective measurements of firmness. Comfort varies widely, as some consumers prefer a soft feel while others need firmer support. For instance, a study by the Sleep Foundation in 2021 highlighted that 70% of individuals prefer medium-firm mattresses for overall sleep satisfaction.

2. Durability: Durability refers to the longevity of a mattress and its ability to retain shape over time. Consumer Reports tests materials for wear and tear resistance through extensive performance testing. For example, latex mattresses often score higher in durability over memory foam due to their natural elasticity. The average lifespan of a quality mattress is around 7-10 years, but some high-end brands may last longer.

3. Temperature Regulation: Mattress materials significantly impact how warm or cool a sleeper feels at night. Consumer Reports examines air circulation, moisture-wicking properties, and heat retention of each mattress model. Gel-infused memory foam, for instance, is praised for its cooling properties. A 2020 study by the National Sleep Foundation found that 60% of people struggle with sleep quality due to overheating.

4. Edge Support: Edge support measures how well a mattress maintains its shape when weight is applied along the edges. Strong edge support prevents sagging and allows for greater usable surface area. Consumer Reports assesses edge support by applying pressure to the sides and measuring any collapse. Mattresses with reinforced edges offer better support, especially for couples sharing a wider sleeping area.

5. Motion Isolation: Motion isolation evaluates how well a mattress absorbs movement, preventing disturbances during sleep. This aspect is crucial for couples or those who share a bed. Consumer Reports performs tests by dropping weights on one side of the mattress and measuring the movement on the opposite side. Foam mattresses typically outperform innerspring models in this area.

6. Ease of Use: Ease of use includes factors like weight, maneuverability, and setup. Consumer Reports takes into account how easily a mattress can be unpacked and set up. Heavy mattresses or those that require special handling may receive lower ratings. Moreover, mattresses that can be conveniently rolled and boxed often score higher.

7. Customer Feedback: Consumer Reports gathers feedback from a wide range of customers. This feedback offers insights into long-term satisfaction and common issues reported by users. Regular surveys and reviews contribute to a more comprehensive understanding of a mattress’s performance beyond initial testing.

Consumer Reports combines these evaluations to provide a well-rounded assessment of each mattress’s overall value and performance.

Which Mattress Brands Are Most Recommended by Consumer Reports?

The most recommended mattress brands by Consumer Reports typically include Saatva, Tempur-Pedic, Purple, and Nectar among others.

1. Saatva
2. Tempur-Pedic
3. Purple
4. Nectar
5. Tuft & Needle

Consumer Reports has evaluated these brands based on various factors such as comfort, durability, support, and price. Let’s dive deeper into these brands and their attributes.

1. Saatva:
   Saatva is often praised for its luxury innerspring mattresses. They offer a range of firmness options, allowing consumers to choose according to their sleep preferences. Saatva mattresses also feature eco-friendly materials and a strong warranty, which appeals to environmentally conscious buyers. A notable example is the Saatva Classic mattress, which combines a coil-on-coil design for support and plush comfort layers.

2. Tempur-Pedic:
   Tempur-Pedic is renowned for its memory foam technology. The brand’s mattresses mold to the body’s shape, providing exceptional pressure relief. Tempur-Pedic mattresses can be more expensive but are frequently rated high for durability and long-lasting comfort. Their TEMPUR material has been shown in studies to improve sleep quality by reducing movement transfer between sleeping partners.

3. Purple:
   Purple stands out with its unique hyper-elastic polymer grid technology. This design allows for airflow and cooling, making it suitable for hot sleepers. Purple mattresses provide a balanced level of support with a softness that many users find appealing. Their alternative construction might not suit everyone’s taste, but it has garnered a loyal following, especially among those seeking breathable options.

4. Nectar:
   Nectar focuses on value, providing memory foam mattresses at competitive prices. They offer a generous trial period and warranty, which gives consumers confidence in their purchase. Nectar mattresses are reported to offer great motion isolation, making them popular among couples. Customer reviews often highlight the comfort during sleep but note that some might find the mattress retains heat.

5. Tuft & Needle:
   Tuft & Needle provides an all-foam mattress known for its adaptability and affordability. The brand’s emphasis on customer feedback has resulted in a product that caters well to average sleeper needs without the high price point. Their T&N Adaptive Foam is designed for support and breathability, offering a comfortable sleeping surface for various body types.

These brands each bring unique strengths to the mattress market, allowing consumers to choose based on personal preference and budget.

What Are the Best Mattress Types According to Consumer Reports?

The best mattress types, according to Consumer Reports, include innerspring, foam, latex, hybrid, and adjustable air mattresses.

1. Innerspring Mattresses
2. Foam Mattresses
3. Latex Mattresses
4. Hybrid Mattresses
5. Adjustable Air Mattresses

Each mattress type offers unique benefits and trade-offs, catering to different preferences and sleeping styles. Below, I provide detailed explanations of each type to clarify their features and performance.

1. Innerspring Mattresses: Innerspring mattresses utilize a core of metal coils for support. The coils provide responsiveness and a bouncy feel. Consumer Reports notes that these mattresses often maintain good air circulation, helping to keep sleepers cool. They are typically more affordable than other types. However, they may not conform as closely to the body, which could lead to pressure points for some sleepers. According to a 2022 study by Sleep Foundation, innerspring mattresses are generally favored by stomach and back sleepers who prefer a firmer surface.

2. Foam Mattresses: Foam mattresses are made primarily of polyurethane foam or memory foam. They offer excellent contouring and pressure relief, making them suitable for side sleepers. Their ability to isolate motion can be beneficial for couples. Consumer Reports highlights that high-density foams provide longevity and durability. However, some foam mattresses may retain heat, which can be uncomfortable for hot sleepers. A 2023 survey by National Sleep Foundation found that 70% of foam mattress owners reported satisfaction related to comfort and support.

3. Latex Mattresses: Latex mattresses are crafted from natural or synthetic latex. They provide a bouncy feel similar to innerspring but with better contouring. They are known for durability and are less likely to retain heat than some foam mattresses. Consumer Reports indicates that natural latex mattresses are eco-friendly and may also be resistant to dust mites and mold. On the downside, they can be heavy and more expensive than other types. Research by the International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health (2021) suggests latex mattresses can reduce the risk of allergies for sensitive individuals.

4. Hybrid Mattresses: Hybrid mattresses combine elements of both innerspring and foam or latex. This design can offer the support of coils along with the comfort of foam or latex layers. According to Consumer Reports, hybrids tend to suit a wide range of sleeping styles due to this balance. They can also help mitigate heat retention by allowing air to flow through the coils. The resource-intensive manufacturing process means hybrids can be pricier. However, they often receive high ratings for comfort and flexibility. A 2023 article in Sleep Review indicates that hybrids are particularly popular among couples who need varying levels of firmness.

5. Adjustable Air Mattresses: Adjustable air mattresses include air chambers that allow users to customize the firmness. They often come with dual controls for couples who prefer different settings. Consumer Reports notes that these mattresses can be suitable for both back and side sleepers. However, potential drawbacks include the reliance on electricity and possible mechanical failure over time. A 2022 review in the Journal of Sleep Research found that adjustability can enhance sleep satisfaction, particularly for those with specific physical needs or preferences.

Which Innerspring Mattresses Are Top Performers?

Several top-performing innerspring mattresses are recognized for their comfort, support, and durability.

1. Saatva Classic
2. Helix Midnight
3. Avocado Green
4. WinkBed
5. Purple Hybrid

These mattresses cater to various preferences with differing features, such as firmness options, eco-friendly materials, and price points. Now, let’s explore these top performers in detail.

1. Saatva Classic:
   The Saatva Classic is an innerspring mattress known for its luxurious design. It features a dual-coil system, combining a coil-on-coil design for support and a plush pillow top for comfort. This mattress is available in three firmness levels: plush soft, luxury firm, and firm, allowing consumers to select based on their personal preferences. Saatva uses eco-friendly materials, earning praise for its sustainability. The mattress has received high ratings from customers and experts alike, often mentioned in reviews for its value and durability.

2. Helix Midnight:
   The Helix Midnight is a popular hybrid mattress blending foam and innerspring materials. It is designed specifically for side sleepers, providing targeted pressure relief for hips and shoulders. The mattress features individually wrapped coils that respond independently to movement, promoting better spinal alignment. Prospective buyers appreciate its customizable firmness options and the company’s sleep quiz, which recommends the best mattress for individual needs. Helix emphasizes its commitment to using high-quality materials, enhancing its reputation.

3. Avocado Green:
   The Avocado Green mattress is an organic option that features a combination of latex and innerspring coils. Made from sustainable materials, including certified organic cotton and natural latex, Avocado appeals to environmentally conscious consumers. It is medium-firm, making it suitable for various sleep positions. Customers often highlight its exceptional breathability and temperature regulation. Reviews frequently commend the mattress for being both comfortable and eco-friendly, aligning with the values of many buyers.

4. WinkBed:
   The WinkBed offers a luxury experience at an affordable price. It features a zoned support system that provides different levels of firmness across the mattress for enhanced spinal alignment. A unique feature is the Tencel cover, which aids in temperature regulation. WinkBeds are available in multiple firmness options, catering to diverse preferences. Customers appreciate the excellent motion isolation, making it suitable for couples. The mattress often receives accolades for combining comfort and support effectively.

5. Purple Hybrid:
   The Purple Hybrid is distinctive for its hyper-elastic polymer grid, which adapts to body shape and prevents pressure points. This innovative design also promotes airflow, helping sleepers stay cool during the night. The combination of coils and the grid allows for targeted support, reducing discomfort. Reviewers frequently mention the unique feel of the Purple mattress, which is different from traditional foam or innerspring options. Its durability and the company’s warranty policy are often highlighted in customer feedback.

These innerspring mattresses stand out for their various features and cater to different preferences while maintaining high quality and customer satisfaction.

How Do Memory Foam Mattresses Rank in Consumer Reports?

Memory foam mattresses generally receive positive rankings in Consumer Reports, noted for their comfort, support, and pressure relief. The reviews highlight several key factors that contribute to their ratings:

• Comfort: Memory foam mattresses often rank high in comfort due to their ability to conform to the body’s shape. This feature helps to distribute weight evenly, reducing pressure points. A 2022 Consumer Reports study indicated that 85% of users found memory foam more comfortable than traditional mattresses.

• Support: These mattresses provide excellent support for the spine and joints. Their ability to adjust to body movements helps in maintaining proper alignment during sleep. The same Consumer Reports survey noted that 90% of users experienced improved back support with memory foam mattresses.

• Durability: Memory foam mattresses tend to have a longer lifespan compared to innerspring mattresses. The materials used in memory foam are designed to resist sagging and maintain comfort over time. According to a 2023 review, many memory foam mattresses lasted over 8 years without substantial wear.

• Motion Isolation: Memory foam is noted for its ability to absorb movement. This quality is beneficial for couples, as it minimizes disturbances when one person shifts positions. Consumer Reports highlighted this characteristic as a significant benefit, especially for light sleepers.

• Temperature Regulation: Some memory foam mattresses incorporate cooling technology, which helps regulate body temperature during sleep. Reports indicate that users who selected cooling memory foam options reported a 30% improvement in comfort from overheating.

These attributes generally lead to favorable consumer satisfaction ratings, making memory foam mattresses a popular choice in the market.

What Makes Hybrid Mattresses Stand Out in Consumer Testing?

Hybrid mattresses stand out in consumer testing due to their unique combination of materials and supportive attributes. They offer a balance of comfort, support, and durability, meeting diverse consumer preferences.

1. Supportive Layering
2. Versatile Comfort
3. Temperature Regulation
4. Durability and Longevity
5. Edge Support
6. Motion Isolation

The variety of attributes highlights the diverse performance aspects of hybrid mattresses. Each point offers insights into different consumer needs and preferences, contributing to their overall appeal.

1. Supportive Layering:
   Supportive layering in hybrid mattresses combines materials like memory foam and innerspring coils. This layered construction provides both contouring support and responsiveness. A study by the National Sleep Foundation (2019) indicates that adequate spine alignment significantly improves sleep quality.

2. Versatile Comfort:
   Versatile comfort in hybrid mattresses caters to various sleeping positions. They are designed to suit side, back, and stomach sleepers. According to a 2022 survey by Mattress Firm, 78% of users reported increased comfort across different sleep positions with a hybrid option.

3. Temperature Regulation:
   Temperature regulation in hybrid mattresses is often enhanced by materials like breathable foams and cooling gel layers. The use of these materials helps dissipate heat, which is crucial for a cooler sleep experience. The Sleep Research Society (2021) emphasizes temperature control as a vital factor in reducing night sweats, improving overall sleep quality.

4. Durability and Longevity:
   Durability and longevity are key attributes of hybrid mattresses. With a good combination of high-quality foam and coil systems, they tend to resist sagging and wear over time. A report by Consumer Reports (2023) notes that hybrid mattresses often last longer than their all-foam counterparts, typically offering a lifespan of 8-10 years.

5. Edge Support:
   Edge support in hybrid mattresses refers to the reinforced borders that prevent sagging when sitting or sleeping near the edge. This feature enhances usable surface area and prevents roll-off. Research by the Sleep Foundation (2019) highlights improved safety and stability with a mattress that offers strong edge support.

6. Motion Isolation:
   Motion isolation is a critical factor for couples sharing a bed. Hybrid mattresses can effectively minimize movement transfer, allowing one partner to move without disturbing the other. A 2020 study by the Journal of Sleep Research states that improved motion isolation contributes significantly to higher satisfaction ratings in couples’ mattresses.

What Insights Can We Gain from Consumer Reports’ Mattress Testing Methodology?

The insights gained from Consumer Reports’ mattress testing methodology include detailed evaluations of mattress comfort, durability, support, and other attributes relevant to consumers.

1. Comfort evaluation
2. Durability testing
3. Support analysis
4. Edge support assessment
5. Temperature regulation
6. Motion isolation
7. Material quality analysis

Consumer Reports focuses on several key aspects of mattress performance.

1. Comfort evaluation: The comfort evaluation assesses how a mattress feels when a person lies on it. This involves subjective user testing where individuals rate their experience based on pressure relief and overall satisfaction. A 2021 survey found that 70% of users prefer a medium-firm mattress for optimal comfort.

2. Durability testing: Durability testing measures how well a mattress withstands wear and tear over time. Consumer Reports conducts mechanical tests to simulate years of use. Studies show that high-density foams tend to last longer than lower density options, giving consumers a clearer picture of value for their investment.

3. Support analysis: The support analysis examines how well a mattress maintains spinal alignment. Consumer Reports uses a combination of pressure mapping and expert evaluations to assess this aspect. Proper support can help prevent back pain. A significant study by the Journal of Chiropractic Medicine (2017) highlights that adequate support can improve sleep quality.

4. Edge support assessment: Edge support assessment evaluates the stability and usability of the mattress edges. Poor edge support may cause users to roll off or feel insecure while sitting. Consumer Reports rates mattresses on how well they perform in this area.

5. Temperature regulation: Temperature regulation addresses the mattress’s ability to dissipate heat during sleep. Consumer Reports tests materials and designs that promote airflow and heat retention. Mattresses with gel-infused foams or breathable covers often score higher in this category.

6. Motion isolation: Motion isolation testing assesses how well a mattress reduces movement transfer. This is particularly important for couples. Consumer Reports uses a heavy weight dropped on one side of the mattress while measuring movement on the other side. A study by Sleep Health Journal (2019) found that mattresses with memory foam excel in this area.

7. Material quality analysis: Material quality analysis looks into the types of materials used in mattresses. Consumer Reports evaluates safety and durability of materials, adhering to safety standards. Their methodology includes testing for harmful chemicals, evaluating certifications like CertiPUR-US or GOTS.

Consumer Reports provides a comprehensive perspective on mattress quality by integrating these evaluations into their ratings.

What Key Buying Tips from Consumer Reports Should You Consider When Choosing a Mattress?

Key buying tips from Consumer Reports when choosing a mattress include evaluating firmness, considering size, assessing materials, testing for comfort, and checking for return policies.

1. Evaluate firmness
2. Consider size
3. Assess materials
4. Test for comfort
5. Check return policies

These key points provide a foundation to understand mattress shopping effectively. They can influence your overall satisfaction with your purchase significantly.

1. Evaluate Firmness: Evaluating firmness helps determine the level of support a mattress provides. Firmness levels typically range from soft to extra firm. Soft mattresses often suit side sleepers, providing pressure relief for shoulders and hips. Conversely, extra firm mattresses benefit back and stomach sleepers by keeping the spine aligned. A study by Consumer Reports highlighted that a medium-firm mattress generally appeals to a broader audience, as it balances comfort and support.

2. Consider Size: Considering size ensures that the mattress fits your bed frame and your personal space. Common sizes include twin, full, queen, and king. Choosing the right size also depends on your sleeping habits and how many people will be sharing the bed. For example, a couple may prefer a king-size mattress for optimal sleep space. According to statistics from the Better Sleep Council, 80% of couples sleep better on larger mattresses.

3. Assess Materials: Assessing materials informs you about durability and comfort levels. Popular materials include memory foam, innerspring, and latex. Memory foam conforms to the body but may retain heat, which could be a concern for some individuals. Innerspring mattresses offer a bouncier feel and greater airflow. Consumer Reports notes that latex mattresses tend to be more durable and environmentally friendly, providing another layer of consideration in your choice.

4. Test for Comfort: Testing for comfort is vital before making a purchase. Many retailers offer in-store demonstrations or trial periods. Lay down on the mattress for at least 10 to 15 minutes to assess comfort. This practice allows you to understand the feel and support level. According to a survey by the National Sleep Foundation, 92% of consumers recommend trying a mattress before buying it.

5. Check Return Policies: Checking return policies gives you peace of mind. Many retailers offer trial periods ranging from 30 to 100 nights, allowing you to return or exchange the mattress if it does not meet your expectations. Understanding these policies helps to mitigate the risk of dissatisfaction. Consumer Reports emphasizes that a flexible return policy can significantly influence a buyer’s final decision, leading to better consumer satisfaction rates.

Related Post:

• Best duvet for memory foam mattress
• Best mattress pad for beautyrest black queen
• Best comforter size for deep mattress queen
• Best mattress dog bed
• Best sheets to fit tempurpedic mattress